
Traumatic Brain Injury Claims
This page covers what traumatic brain injury means clinically, why TBI claims are legally complex, who can make a claim and what the process involves.
What is a traumatic brain injury?
A traumatic brain injury (TBI) is an injury to the brain caused by an external force. The force may come from a blow, jolt, bump or penetrating injury to the head. It can also occur when the head decelerates rapidly, as happens in many road accidents, causing the brain to move inside the skull.
Not every head injury causes a brain injury. A head injury covers physical damage to any structure of the head from a trauma. A brain injury is narrower: it involves damage to brain tissue itself, established through clinical signs or investigation.
How TBI is classified by severity
Clinicians classify TBI as mild, moderate or severe, using three main markers: the Glasgow Coma Scale (GCS) score at presentation, how long the person was unconscious (loss of consciousness, or LOC), and the duration of post-traumatic amnesia (PTA). PTA refers to the period after an injury when a person is awake but cannot reliably form new memories or is confused and disoriented.
Using those markers, the classification broadly works as follows:
Mild TBI: GCS score of 13 to 15, LOC under 30 minutes, PTA under 24 hours. Australian clinical guidelines, including the current NSW guideline from the Agency for Clinical Innovation, include an initial GCS score of 13 within the mild TBI range. That guideline notes, however, that a score of 13 is associated with higher rates of intracranial injury and outcomes that more closely resemble moderate TBI. An earlier NSW Health policy placed GCS 13 in the moderate category. The classification of this injury level remains an area of clinical variation across guidelines.
Moderate TBI: GCS score of 9 to 12, LOC ranging from half an hour to 24 hours, PTA from 1 to 7 days.
Severe TBI: GCS score of 8 or below, LOC more than 24 hours, PTA more than 7 days.
The classification at the time of injury does not always predict how a person will be affected long term. People with mild TBI can have persistent, disabling symptoms. People with severe TBI can recover more function than initial assessments suggest.
Types of TBI
TBIs are often divided into focal and diffuse injuries.
Focal injuries affect a specific area and include contusions (bruising to brain tissue), haematomas (collections of blood) and lacerations. A subdural haematoma is a bleed between the outer lining of the brain and the brain surface, and it can cause pressure on the surrounding tissue. An epidural haematoma is a bleed between the skull and the outer lining of the brain.
Diffuse injuries affect the brain more broadly. The most significant is diffuse axonal injury (DAI), which occurs when the brain moves rapidly inside the skull, causing the nerve fibres (axons) to stretch and tear. DAI disrupts how the brain transmits signals and can cause profound and lasting changes even when imaging appears relatively normal.
Secondary injury is damage that develops after the initial trauma. Brain swelling, bleeding and the body's inflammatory response can cause further injury to tissue that was not damaged in the original event. Secondary injury can develop over hours or days following the initial trauma, which is why early medical attention and monitoring are important.
Symptoms of TBI
Symptoms depend on the severity and location of the injury. They are often grouped as physical, cognitive and emotional.
- Physical: headache, dizziness, nausea, fatigue, difficulty sleeping, sensitivity to light or noise, problems with balance and coordination, and in more severe cases, seizures or physical weakness.
- Cognitive: difficulty concentrating, problems with memory and learning, slower processing speed, problems with planning and organising, and difficulty finding words.
- Emotional and behavioural: irritability, anxiety, depression, emotional swings, and in some cases, changes in personality or impulse control.
Many people with TBI also experience post-traumatic amnesia during the acute phase and may have no memory of the injury or the period immediately before or after it.
Who can make a TBI claim?
A traumatic brain injury claim may be possible where the injury was caused by:
- a road accident, as a driver, passenger, cyclist or pedestrian
- a workplace incident, including a fall, being struck by a falling object or an equipment failure
- a fall in a public place or on someone's premises
- a sporting or recreational incident involving the negligence of another person or organisation
- medical treatment that fell below the standard expected of a competent practitioner
- an assault or other violent act
The type of claim available depends on how the injury happened and the state or territory where it occurred. Some claims run through workers compensation or motor accident schemes. Others require proving that another party was at fault and failed in a duty of care. You can read more about how these pathways work on our brain injury claims page.
A family member or carer may enquire on behalf of a person who cannot make an enquiry themselves. Where the injured person is unable to manage legal proceedings, there are formal steps for a family member or another person to act as their litigation guardian.
What makes TBI claims legally complex?
Several features of TBI make claims in this area more involved than many other personal injury matters.
- The injury may not show on standard imaging. CT and MRI scans may be normal even where a person has a significant brain injury. This is particularly common in mild TBI and diffuse axonal injury. Abnormal results on neuropsychological testing may be the primary evidence of the injury's effects.
- Assessing permanent impairment takes time. Most schemes require the injury to have stabilised and to be unlikely to change substantially before a formal impairment assessment can be done. Because brain injuries can continue to change for a year or more after the event, this can mean a long wait before the claim can be fully valued.
- The long-term effects are uncertain at the outset. Settling too soon, before the full picture of the injury is known, carries the risk of receiving less compensation than the injury ultimately costs. In most schemes and courts, settlements are final.
- Evidence requires multiple specialists. A TBI claim typically involves reports from the treating team, a neurologist or neurosurgeon, a neuropsychologist, and often an occupational therapist or vocational expert. Coordinating and funding that evidence takes time and skill.
- Psychological effects can be significant but harder to quantify. Anxiety, depression and cognitive difficulties are recognised effects of TBI and may be claimed, but they require careful evidence that connects them to the injury rather than to other causes.
- The scheme rules vary significantly. What a person can claim, what thresholds apply, and how long they have to claim all depend on the state, the scheme and how the injury occurred.
Evidence in a TBI claim
The starting point is medical records from the hospital and any treating practitioners. From there, claims of this kind typically draw on:
- specialist reports from a neurologist or neurosurgeon
- neuropsychological assessment, which tests cognitive function across a range of domains including memory, attention, processing speed and executive function
- occupational therapy and vocational reports on the impact on work and daily activities
- employment and income records
- care and support records
- witness statements about the person's condition before and after the injury
Time limits
Time limits apply to every type of TBI claim. In some states, a form must be lodged within weeks of the injury. In others, the limit runs from the date of the accident, the date the injury is first linked to the accident, or the date the person first consults a lawyer. In some cases a time limit starts or becomes shorter from the day you first ask a lawyer about a claim.
If a time limit may be close, tell us when you send your enquiry.
Frequently asked questions
This page provides general information, not legal advice.